1. Introduction
Maritime transport is one of the backbone methods of international trade. Preferred for its ability to move large volumes of high-value goods economically and efficiently, it also brings legal risks and a high potential for disputes. In particular, situations involving cargo damage, short delivery, or non-delivery often give rise to disputes between the carrier and the consignor regarding liability.
This article examines the legal responsibilities of the parties involved, the potential legal remedies, and the framework of carriage contracts, transport documents, and fault allocation under Turkish Commercial Law and international maritime practice.
2. The Carriage Relationship and Essential Documents
2.1. Contract of Carriage (Freight Contract)
A freight contract is entered into between the consignor and the carrier, providing for the carriage of goods by sea from one port to another. Though it may be oral, in practice it is typically in written form, often evidenced by the transport documents. The contract generally includes:
- Description of the goods,
- Port of loading and discharge,
- Freight charges,
- Estimated delivery period,
- Clauses on insurance, damages, and liability.
2.2. Transport Documents: Bill of Lading and Sea Waybill
- Bill of Lading: A key transport document that serves as evidence of the contract of carriage and also represents title to the goods. It is required for delivery of the cargo.
- Sea Waybill: Unlike the bill of lading, it does not represent title to goods. It merely evidences the carriage relationship, and delivery is made upon identification.
Information on these documents (type, quantity of goods, loading dates, etc.) is vital in determining liability in case of damage or loss.
3. Types of Cargo Loss and Their Legal Consequences
3.1. Physical Damage to Cargo
Breakage, spoilage, or water damage during transport triggers the carrier’s liability. However, if the damage results from:
- Improper packaging by the consignor,
- Failure to declare dangerous goods,
- Acts of God (storms, earthquakes),
- Navigational error,
then the carrier may be relieved of liability.
3.2. Short Delivery
If less cargo is delivered than documented, the carrier is presumed liable unless proven otherwise. However, if:
- The shortfall resulted from improper loading by the consignor,
- There was a weighing or declaration error,
the carrier may be exonerated.
3.3. Non-Delivery
Where the cargo is completely lost, stolen, or delivered to the wrong party, the carrier bears strict liability. Still, if the carrier proves the loss was due to circumstances beyond their control, liability may be mitigated or avoided.
4. Liability Disputes Between Carrier and Consignor
4.1. Carrier’s Liability
Under Article 1180 of the Turkish Commercial Code (TCC), the carrier must deliver the goods in proper condition and as agreed. The carrier may be exonerated if the damage resulted from:
- Inadequate packaging by the consignor (TCC Art. 1186),
- Undeclared dangerous goods (TCC Art. 1189),
- Force majeure (war, natural disaster),
- Navigational or operational errors of the master or crew.
4.2. Consignor’s Liability
The consignor is responsible for behaviors that cause damage to the carrier or others, such as:
- Misleading declarations,
- Faulty loading,
- Concealing dangerous goods.
The consignor also has a duty of care regarding:
- Accurate documentation,
- Sufficient packaging,
- Providing correct loading instructions.
Court of Cassation 11th Civil Chamber, 2018/10769 E., 2020/1526 K.
“If the damage during transportation stems from packaging or loading faults attributable to the consignor, the carrier is not liable unless proven otherwise.”
5. Legal Remedies and Time Limits
5.1. Notice Requirement
The consignee must inspect the goods at delivery. Obvious damage must be reported immediately, and hidden damage must be reported within 3 days. Otherwise, the goods are presumed to have been delivered in good condition (TCC Art. 1201).
5.2. Compensation Claims
The injured party (consignor or consignee) may file a compensation lawsuit against the carrier, claiming the value of the lost or damaged goods.
- Competent court: Commercial Court of First Instance.
- Limitation period: 1 year from the date of delivery (TCC Art. 1248). This is a mandatory period.
5.3. Insurance and Recourse
If the cargo was insured, the insurance company may cover the loss and subsequently initiate a recourse action against the carrier. In such cases, fault allocation between the consignor and the carrier is reassessed.
6. Conclusion and Recommendations
In maritime transport, damage to or loss of cargo frequently leads to legal disputes between carriers and consignors. In such cases:
- The content of the freight contract,
- Declarations in transport documents,
- Responsibility for loading and packaging,
- Notification deadlines and statutes of limitation
are crucial in determining liability.
To minimize the risk of disputes:
- Written and detailed contracts should be drafted,
- Bills of lading and other documents must be meticulously prepared,
- Cargo should be insured,
- Damage inspection reports must be created upon delivery,
- Each party must be aware of its legal obligations.
If damage or loss occurs, swift legal consultation is essential to protect rights. Seeking support from an experienced maritime lawyer can significantly reduce the risk of forfeiting claims due to procedural issues.
Yanıt yok