Introduction
Possession of narcotic substances for personal use under Article 191 of the Turkish Penal Code is a distinct offense in Turkish criminal law, separated from drug trafficking (Article 188 TPC). While trafficking is punished as a crime against public health with severe penalties, Article 191 addresses the situation where individuals hold narcotics only for their own consumption.
For foreigners living in or visiting Turkey, understanding the difference between personal use and trafficking is critical. A misunderstanding of quantity, intent, or circumstances can determine whether an individual faces rehabilitation-oriented measures or decades of imprisonment. This article provides a legal framework and comprehensive overview of Article 191, including its elements, penalties, alternatives to imprisonment, judicial practice, and practical advice for foreigners.
Legal Framework
1. Turkish Penal Code (Law No. 5237) – Article 191
Article 191 criminalizes the purchase, acceptance, or possession of narcotic or stimulant substances for personal use. Unlike Article 188, it does not require intent to distribute or traffic.
2. Related Laws and Provisions
- Article 188 TPC: Drug production and trafficking.
- Article 192 TPC: Effective remorse (provides mitigation for cooperation).
- Law No. 2313 on the Control of Narcotic Substances: Defines substances and implements international conventions.
- Probation Law (Denetimli Serbestlik Kanunu): Governs treatment and probation measures.
3. International Context
Turkey’s legal system incorporates international standards, including the 1961 Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs and the 1988 UN Convention against Illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs, but adopts a more rehabilitation-oriented approach when the offense is purely personal use.
Elements of the Crime
1. Material Act (Actus Reus)
- Purchase: Buying narcotics for personal consumption.
- Acceptance: Receiving narcotics from another person.
- Possession: Keeping narcotics, regardless of location (pocket, home, car, etc.), as long as intent is personal use.
2. Mental Element (Mens Rea)
- Requires intent to use personally, not to sell or distribute.
- If evidence suggests commercial intent (large quantities, packaging, scales, cash, etc.), courts may reclassify the act as trafficking under Article 188.
3. Object of the Crime
- Narcotic or stimulant substances as defined by Turkish law and international conventions: cannabis, heroin, cocaine, ecstasy, methamphetamine, synthetic opioids, etc.
Penalties and Measures under Article 191
1. Basic Sanction
- Imprisonment of 2 to 5 years for possession of narcotics for personal use.
2. Alternative Measures
Instead of immediate imprisonment, Turkish law favors rehabilitation and treatment:
- Postponement of Prosecution: Prosecutor may suspend proceedings for 5 years, during which the suspect must comply with probation conditions.
- Probation (Denetimli Serbestlik): The individual may undergo mandatory treatment, psychological counseling, or drug testing.
- Dismissal of Case: If the probation is successfully completed, the case is dismissed without a criminal record.
3. Failure to Comply
- If the suspect violates probation rules (e.g., refuses treatment, continues use), the suspended prosecution may be reactivated, and imprisonment may follow.
Judicial Practice and Yargıtay Precedents
- Distinguishing Use vs. Trafficking: Yargıtay (Court of Cassation) emphasizes the importance of quantity, packaging, and intent. Even possession of small amounts may be classified as trafficking if indicators suggest commercial intent.
- Emphasis on Rehabilitation: Turkish courts often prefer probation and treatment for first-time offenders.
- Recidivism: Repeat offenses are treated more harshly, often leading to imprisonment.
Practical Implications for Foreigners
1. Sensitivity of Turkish Authorities
Turkey’s geographic location as a bridge between Asia and Europe makes it a strict jurisdiction on narcotics. Foreigners in possession of even small quantities may face immediate detention.
2. Risks for Foreigners
- Language Barrier: Misunderstandings in intent (personal use vs. trafficking) can occur without proper legal defense.
- Pre-trial Detention: Foreigners are often considered flight risks; detention pending trial is more likely.
- Deportation: Even if probation or treatment is granted, foreigners may face deportation after proceedings.
3. Defense Rights
- Right to an Interpreter: Guaranteed during all stages.
- Legal Counsel: Foreigners should seek specialized criminal defense lawyers.
- Consular Notification: Foreign embassies are informed of detention.
Defenses and Legal Remedies
- Personal Use Defense: Demonstrating that the narcotics were strictly for consumption, not distribution.
- Treatment Compliance: Showing genuine efforts at rehabilitation.
- Procedural Defenses: Contesting unlawful search and seizure.
- Appeals: Decisions can be appealed to higher courts, including Yargıtay.
Conclusion
The possession of narcotic substances for personal use under Article 191 of the Turkish Penal Code is treated differently from trafficking. Turkish law emphasizes rehabilitation, probation, and treatment rather than imprisonment, particularly for first-time offenders. However, the distinction between personal use and trafficking can be thin, and foreigners may face stricter procedural measures such as detention and deportation.
For foreigners in Turkey, understanding Article 191 is crucial: compliance with probation and treatment measures may prevent imprisonment and permanent criminal records. Nevertheless, the risks of misclassification, recidivism, or non-compliance require immediate legal assistance from a criminal defense attorney.
Yanıt yok