1) What Is a Contested Divorce in Turkey?
A contested divorce in Turkey is a divorce case where spouses cannot agree on either (i) the divorce itself or (ii) the consequences of divorce—such as child custody, visitation, alimony, property division, compensation (material/moral damages), and use of the family home. Unlike an uncontested (mutual) divorce, contested cases require the judge to determine fault, evaluate evidence, and rule on disputed claims.
Contested divorce is litigated primarily before Family Courts (Aile Mahkemesi). Where a Family Court is not established, the case may be handled by a civil court acting as a Family Court.
2) Legal Grounds for Contested Divorce in Turkey
Turkish law recognizes both special grounds and a general ground for divorce. Choosing the right legal ground matters because it affects burden of proof, limitation periods, and fault analysis.
A) Special Grounds (Fault-Based or Condition-Based)
Commonly invoked special grounds include:
- Adultery (Zina): Requires proof that one spouse had a sexual relationship outside marriage. Timing matters because Turkish law includes strict time limits to file after learning of adultery, and “forgiveness” may eliminate the right to sue on this ground.
- Attempt on life, severe ill-treatment, or degrading treatment: Typically supported by medical records, criminal complaints, protection orders, or witness testimony.
- Dishonorable life or conduct: Applies where a spouse’s lifestyle causes the marital union to become unbearable (courts look for seriousness, continuity, and impact on the marriage).
- Desertion (Abandonment): Not simply “leaving home.” It usually requires a legally compliant warning/notice process and a minimum separation period.
- Mental illness: Requires official medical reports and a showing that cohabitation is intolerable and the condition is not expected to improve within a meaningful timeframe.
B) General Ground: Irretrievable Breakdown of Marriage
The most frequently used ground in practice is the irretrievable breakdown of the marital union (often described as “fundamental breakdown”). This ground is flexible and covers a wide range of situations: chronic conflict, loss of trust, emotional abandonment, persistent disrespect, and other patterns making continuation unreasonable.
3) Fault and Its Legal Consequences
In Turkish contested divorce litigation, fault can affect:
- Compensation claims (material and moral),
- Alimony (maintenance) eligibility and amount in certain contexts,
- Strategic positioning during settlement negotiations.
However, custody is primarily assessed under the best interests of the child standard. Fault between spouses is not automatically decisive for custody unless it directly impacts the child’s welfare.
4) Evidence in a Contested Divorce: What Works (and What Backfires)
Evidence is often the decisive factor. Turkish courts generally consider:
- Witness testimony: Still one of the most influential forms of evidence, especially for ongoing patterns (violence, neglect, insults, substance abuse, abandonment).
- Messages, emails, social media posts: Useful to show threats, insults, admissions, or public humiliation. Courts focus on authenticity and context.
- Police records, criminal complaints, protection orders: Strong support in violence-related cases.
- Medical reports and hospital records: Critical for physical harm and psychological impact.
- Photographs/videos: Can be persuasive if obtained lawfully and presented with proper explanation.
- Expert reports: Frequently used for psychological assessments, financial evaluations, or parenting-related inquiries.
- Economic and social status investigations: Courts can request official inquiries to assess income, living conditions, and child-related expenses.
Unlawfully Obtained Evidence: A Serious Risk
A common mistake is collecting evidence in a way that violates privacy—such as hacking accounts, installing spyware, recording private conversations unlawfully, or entering restricted spaces. Such evidence can be:
- excluded by the court,
- and may create criminal exposure depending on the method.
A safer strategy is to build a case with lawful, verifiable, and proportionate evidence, and use court-assisted measures for critical records when available.
5) Interim Measures During the Case (Temporary Court Orders)
Contested divorce cases take time. To prevent harm during the proceedings, Turkish courts can order interim measures, such as:
- Temporary custody and visitation schedule,
- Temporary alimony (support) and child support,
- Protection measures in violence allegations,
- Family home arrangements and sometimes restrictions to preserve stability.
These orders can be crucial for the child’s routine and for financial survival during the lawsuit.
6) A Realistic Timeline: From Filing to Finalization
There is no single fixed timeline, but the process often follows a predictable structure:
- Pre-filing preparation (2–6 weeks): Evidence collection, witness planning, drafting petitions, setting claims (custody/alimony/compensation).
- Filing and service of process (1–3 months): Service can take longer if a spouse is abroad or evasive.
- Exchange of petitions (several weeks to months): The respondent files an answer; the claimant may reply; the respondent may submit a rejoinder.
- Preliminary hearing (often 2–6 months after filing): The court sets the roadmap, identifies disputed issues, and may order interim measures.
- Evidence phase (6–18+ months): Witnesses are heard, experts may be appointed, institutions respond to court requests.
- Judgment hearing and decision: The court announces the decision and later issues the reasoned judgment.
- Appeal stages (months to over a year): Regional appellate review is common; further review may be available depending on the case structure.
What usually makes the case longer? Multiple witnesses, foreign service, expert reports, high-conflict custody disputes, and complex asset issues (companies, hidden transfers, cross-border property).
Conclusion
A contested divorce in Turkey is evidence-driven and procedure-heavy. The strongest outcomes usually come from: (i) choosing the right legal grounds, (ii) building lawful and consistent evidence, and (iii) securing interim protection for children and finances early. When managed strategically, contested divorce litigation can protect rights while also increasing the likelihood of a realistic settlement.
Yanıt yok