Introduction
When establishing a business in Turkey, one of the most important strategic decisions investors must make is choosing the appropriate legal structure. The two most commonly used corporate forms are:
- Joint Stock Company (Anonim Şirket – A.Ş.)
- Limited Liability Company (Limited Şirket – Ltd.)
Both structures provide limited liability protection, but they differ significantly in terms of capital requirements, governance rules, share transfer flexibility, regulatory oversight, and suitability for investment transactions.
For foreign investors, venture capital funds, startups, and multinational corporations, understanding the legal differences between a Joint Stock Company and a Limited Company in Turkey is critical for long-term operational and strategic planning.
This article provides a comprehensive comparison of both company types.
1. Legal Framework
Both A.Ş. and Ltd. companies are regulated under:
- Turkish Commercial Code (TCC) No. 6102
However, detailed provisions differ significantly.
2. Legal Personality and Limited Liability
Both company types:
- Have separate legal personality
- Provide limited liability to shareholders
Shareholders are liable only up to their capital contribution.
However, in practice, there are important distinctions regarding public debts.
3. Minimum Capital Requirements
Joint Stock Company (A.Ş.)
- Minimum capital: 250,000 TRY
- At least 25% must be paid before registration
Limited Company (Ltd.)
- Minimum capital: 50,000 TRY
- Capital may be paid within 24 months
A.Ş. requires higher initial capital commitment.
4. Number of Shareholders
A.Ş.
- Minimum: 1 shareholder
- No upper limit
Ltd.
- Minimum: 1 shareholder
- Maximum: 50 shareholders
Ltd. companies are not suitable for large shareholder bases.
5. Share Transfer Rules
One of the most critical differences:
A.Ş.
- Shares are freely transferable unless restricted in Articles of Association
- Share certificates may be issued
- Transfer is relatively simple
Ltd.
- Share transfer requires:
- Notarized agreement
- General assembly approval
- Trade registry registration
Ltd. structure is less flexible for investment exits.
6. Corporate Governance Structure
A.Ş.
- Governed by Board of Directors
- Board may consist of one or more members
- Corporate governance rules more developed
Ltd.
- Managed by one or more managers
- Governance is simpler
A.Ş. structure is more suitable for institutional governance.
7. Suitability for Public Offering
Only Joint Stock Companies:
- May go public
- May be listed on Borsa Istanbul
- May issue bonds and other capital market instruments
Ltd. companies cannot be publicly traded.
For future IPO plans, A.Ş. is mandatory.
8. Tax Treatment
Both company types are subject to:
- Corporate income tax
- VAT
- Withholding taxes
Corporate tax rate is generally identical.
However, certain capital market tax advantages may apply only to A.Ş.
9. Liability for Public Debts
This is a critical distinction.
A.Ş.
Shareholders are generally not personally liable for unpaid public debts.
Ltd.
Shareholders may be secondarily liable for unpaid tax and social security debts in proportion to their capital share.
This creates higher risk in Ltd. structure.
10. Audit Requirements
Certain large companies must undergo independent audit.
Public companies (A.Ş.) are more frequently subject to audit obligations.
Ltd. companies are generally subject to audit only if they exceed financial thresholds.
11. Capital Increase and Reduction
A.Ş.
- More flexible capital increase mechanisms
- Registered capital system available
Ltd.
- More rigid capital amendment process
Investors often prefer A.Ş. for future financing rounds.
12. Dividend Distribution
Both company types may distribute dividends.
However:
- A.Ş. dividend rules are more structured.
- Public A.Ş. must comply with CMB dividend regulations.
13. Administrative Complexity
A.Ş.
- More formal
- More documentation
- Board meeting requirements
Ltd.
- Simpler structure
- Less bureaucratic
Small businesses often prefer Ltd.
14. Foreign Investor Perspective
Foreign investors generally prefer A.Ş. because:
- Easier share transfer
- Stronger corporate governance
- Better suited for M&A
- No secondary liability for public debts
Ltd. may be suitable for small-scale operations.
15. Cost Considerations
A.Ş.:
- Higher capital
- Slightly higher formation costs
Ltd.:
- Lower capital requirement
- Lower initial cost
However, long-term strategic flexibility may justify A.Ş. costs.
16. Conversion Between Company Types
It is possible to:
- Convert Ltd. into A.Ş.
This process requires:
- Expert report
- General assembly approval
- Trade registry registration
Many startups begin as Ltd. and later convert to A.Ş.
17. Comparison Table
| Criteria | Joint Stock Company (A.Ş.) | Limited Company (Ltd.) |
|---|---|---|
| Minimum Capital | 250,000 TRY | 50,000 TRY |
| Shareholder Limit | No limit | Max 50 |
| Share Transfer | Easy | Notarized & approved |
| Public Offering | Possible | Not possible |
| Public Debt Liability | No | Possible secondary liability |
| Governance | Board of Directors | Managers |
| Suitable for VC/PE | Yes | Limited |
18. Which Structure Is Better?
It depends on:
- Investment scale
- Growth plans
- Exit strategy
- Risk tolerance
- Regulatory requirements
For scalable businesses, startups seeking venture capital, or companies planning IPO, A.Ş. is generally preferred.
For small family-owned businesses, Ltd. may suffice.
Conclusion
The choice between a Joint Stock Company and a Limited Company in Turkey is not merely procedural—it is strategic. While both structures provide limited liability, they differ significantly in governance flexibility, shareholder liability exposure, share transfer mechanisms, and suitability for investment transactions.
For foreign investors and growth-oriented businesses, the Joint Stock Company structure typically offers greater flexibility and legal protection. However, for smaller operations, the Limited Company remains a practical and cost-effective option.
Careful legal evaluation before incorporation is essential to align corporate structure with long-term business objectives.
Yanıt yok