Can a child’s right to life depend on the geographical location of their birth?
Can a mother’s right to reunite with her child be sacrificed for the political and economic interests of states?
Can a person’s language, religion, identity, or nationality ever justify depriving them of their freedom?
From a legal perspective, the answer to these questions is unequivocal: No.
Yet, events unfolding across different parts of the world reveal a profound gap between universally recognized principles of law and their implementation.
Today, Palestinians struggling to survive in Gaza and Uyghur Turks facing severe restrictions on their fundamental rights and freedoms in East Turkestan raise the same fundamental question, despite their different circumstances:
Will international law be applied according to the interests of powerful states, or will it protect the rights of all human beings without discrimination?
This question must be addressed not only to politicians but also to lawyers, academics, human rights defenders, and everyone who believes in justice.
1. East Turkestan: A People’s Struggle for Identity and Freedom
East Turkestan, the region officially designated by the People’s Republic of China as the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region, has long been at the center of serious international human rights concerns.
Allegations of severe violations of the rights of Uyghur Turks to practice their religion, preserve their cultural identity, use their native language, and enjoy personal freedoms have been documented in reports by international institutions.
In an assessment published on August 31, 2022, the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights concluded that the arbitrary and discriminatory detention of Uyghurs and members of other predominantly Muslim communities may constitute international crimes, particularly crimes against humanity.
This assessment carries profound legal significance.
Although states possess the authority to maintain security within their territories, such authority does not grant them unlimited power to restrict fundamental human rights.
Chinese authorities have defended their policies as measures aimed at combating terrorism and extremism. However, the pursuit of security cannot justify arbitrary detention, torture, discrimination, or unlawful interference with freedom of religion.
The ability to speak one’s native language, practice one’s faith, and live with one’s family is not a privilege granted at the discretion of a state.
These are fundamental rights inherent in human dignity.
The issue of East Turkestan concerns not only Uyghur Turks but every legal professional who believes in the universality of human rights.
Remaining silent when a community is deprived of its rights because of its identity weakens the moral and legal resistance against similar violations elsewhere.
2. Gaza: A Test of the Right to Life and Human Dignity
The humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza has raised serious questions about the effectiveness of international legal institutions in the modern world.
Civilians affected by the devastating consequences of war continue to face enormous difficulties in accessing the most basic necessities of life, including shelter, food, healthcare, and security.
According to the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA), in its report dated November 13, 2026, heavy rainfall affected approximately 46,000 households in Gaza and damaged more than 40,000 shelters.
These circumstances demonstrate that the ongoing humanitarian crisis extends beyond armed hostilities and encompasses serious threats to safe housing and basic living conditions.
Yet even war is governed by law.
One of the fundamental principles of international humanitarian law is the obligation to distinguish between civilians and those participating in hostilities.
Indiscriminate attacks are prohibited. Military operations must comply with the principles of proportionality and the obligation to take feasible precautions.
Deliberately targeting civilians and taking hostages are unlawful, regardless of who commits such acts. The attacks against civilians and hostage-taking carried out by Hamas and other armed groups on October 7, 2023, must also be assessed under these principles.
However, the existence of one unlawful attack cannot provide legal justification for the collective punishment of another population.
One crime cannot justify another. No military objective can diminish the value of a child’s right to life.
3. What Does the International Court of Justice Say?
Approaching the situation in Gaza and Palestine solely through emotional arguments risks overlooking significant developments in international law.
In proceedings instituted by South Africa against Israel under the Genocide Convention, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) issued orders indicating provisional measures on January 26, March 28, and May 24, 2024.
In its order of May 24, 2024, the Court reaffirmed previously indicated measures and prescribed additional measures concerning military operations in Rafah and the provision of humanitarian assistance.
An important legal distinction must be emphasized: Orders indicating provisional measures do not constitute a final judicial determination that genocide has been committed.
Nevertheless, these decisions underscore the seriousness of the rights requiring protection under international law.
Furthermore, in its advisory opinion of July 19, 2024, the International Court of Justice concluded that Israel’s continued presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory was unlawful and emphasized the importance of the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination.
These legal findings demonstrate that states remain bound by international law, regardless of their political or military power.
The strength of the law lies not merely in the ability of courts to deliver judgments, but in ensuring that those judgments are effectively implemented.
One of humanity’s greatest challenges today lies precisely in this distinction.
4. Human Rights Are Not Reserved for the Powerful
Article 1 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted on December 10, 1948, establishes that all human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.
Article 3 recognizes the rights to life, liberty, and security of person; Article 5 prohibits torture; Article 9 protects against arbitrary arrest and detention; and Article 18 guarantees freedom of thought, conscience, and religion.
These principles are not privileges belonging to any particular nation, religion, or state.
Under the law, the right to life of a Palestinian child cannot be considered more or less valuable than that of a Uyghur child.
Defending the freedom of one community while remaining indifferent to the suffering of another is inconsistent with the principle that human rights are universal.
Certainly, the legal circumstances of Gaza and East Turkestan are different.
In Gaza, the law of occupation, international humanitarian law, and the Palestinian people’s right to self-determination are central legal issues.
In East Turkestan, particular attention must be paid to the prohibition of discrimination, personal liberty, freedom of religion, the protection of cultural identity, and allegations of arbitrary detention.
Despite these differences, both situations are governed by one fundamental principle:
State sovereignty does not confer the authority to destroy human dignity.
5. Can Legal Professionals Afford to Remain Silent?
As a lawyer, I believe that law is not merely a collection of statutes, legal arguments, and claims presented before courts.
Law is also the common language through which humanity struggles to protect human dignity.
As legal professionals, when we object to the unlawful deprivation of one person’s liberty, we must be prepared to defend that same principle for another human being anywhere in the world.
The moment we accept that justice applies only to those close to us, our fellow citizens, or people who share our beliefs, we abandon the universality of the law.
The legal profession therefore bears significant responsibilities in responding to international human rights violations.
Bar associations, law faculties, academics, and human rights organizations must examine serious violations through rigorous research, support their documentation, and advocate the effective implementation of legal accountability mechanisms.
Every legitimate instrument offered by international law should be used to promote victims’ access to justice, determine the fate of missing persons, secure the release of those arbitrarily detained, protect civilians, and ensure that humanitarian assistance reaches those in need.
This responsibility does not belong exclusively to legal professionals.
Every member of society can contribute by seeking reliable information, supporting the work of human rights organizations, and drawing attention to violations through peaceful and lawful means.
The pursuit of justice must never become the exclusive cause of a particular political ideology or community.
Justice is truly justice only when it belongs to everyone.
6. Silence Is Not Neutrality
History does not merely examine those responsible for grave human rights violations. It also questions how others responded when those violations occurred.
Recognizing the suffering of someone in Gaza who has lost their home, family, and security, or listening to a person in East Turkestan who alleges that their rights have been violated because of their identity or faith, does not amount to hostility toward any state or nation.
On the contrary, defending human rights also means opposing the demonization of individuals because of their nationality or religion.
Criticizing the policies of a government is not the same as targeting the people of that country.
The pursuit of legal accountability must be founded on evidence rather than anger, justice rather than revenge, and human dignity rather than discrimination.
The effectiveness of international law depends not only on international courts but also on the consistent defense of legal principles.
The purpose of law is not to declare that the powerful are right, but to ensure that those who are right can be protected against power.
Conclusion: Freedom Belongs Not to a Particular Land, but to Humanity
If a child in Gaza wishes to sleep in safety, a mother in East Turkestan longs to reunite with her family, or a person elsewhere in the world seeks to express their thoughts without fear, all these aspirations share one foundation: human dignity.
We do not need to speak the same language, follow the same religion, or belong to the same nation as a victim in order to defend their human rights.
Sometimes, the first requirement of defending justice is to look beyond the identity of the victim and recognize the injustice they have suffered.
Our responsibility as legal professionals is not simply to explain existing laws, but to strive to ensure that those laws provide meaningful protection in people’s lives.
Defending the liberty of a person arbitrarily detained, the life of a child caught in war, and the fundamental rights of a community subjected to discrimination because of its identity, wherever these violations occur, represents the very purpose of law.
To defend the right to life in Gaza and the freedom and human dignity of people in East Turkestan is, ultimately, to defend the equal application of the law to all humanity.
And we must never forget:
If oppression knows no borders, neither should the pursuit of justice.
For when one human being is deprived of freedom, it is not only that individual who suffers; the collective conscience of humanity is wounded as well.
No Responses